Ep. 65 - Jennifer Magley - Professional Menace
Listen while you read
Put your email in here, and I’ll send you this blog every week with the episode release.
Important links and mentions
Third Space Indy is supported by:
Episode Summary
Today's guest is Jennifer Magley, a local content creator, emcee, and sidequester. She recently finished her 100 stages in 365 days quest, and I'm fortunate to have sat down with her at Borage in Speedway as one of her final stages before she rounded it out with stage 100 on the Conversation Piece podcast. Jennifer has long been one of the most requested guests for the show, and I'm so thankful because she's electric, and I hope you hear how much genuine fun I had talking with her.
SPONSOR
City Rising — cityrising.org
MUSIC
Jennasen — "Scared Rabbit"
TIMESTAMPS
00:00 Cold Open
01:08 Intro
01:59 Meet Jennifer
02:25 Borage & Safe Spaces
05:47 Brownsburg vs. Indy
09:15 Stooge Quest & Pat McAfee
12:39 Community & Belonging
18:24 Stage Quest Stories
26:24 Wardrobe & Style
30:04 City Rising Question
35:00 Money & Investment in Indy
38:43 Husband Rob
42:06 Talking to Women
54:13 Style Evolution
58:03 Crisis & Booking Gigs
01:03:22 Community & Privilege
01:15:00 Where to Find Jennifer
Episode Transcript
Jennifer Magley
===
Michael Zarick: [00:00:00] Today's guest is Jennifer Magley, a local content creator, emcee, and sidequester. She recently finished her 100 stages in 365 days quest, and I'm fortunate to have sat down with her at Borage in Speedway as one of her final stages before she rounded it out with stage 100 on the Conversation Piece podcast. Jennifer has long been one of the most requested guests for the show, and I'm so thankful because this woman is electric, and I hope you hear how much genuine fun I had talking with her.
If you enjoy conversations like this, consider supporting Third Space Indy. You can do that by going to support. thirdspaceindy .com to pay my bus fare, by liking and subscribing on or leaving a review on your preferred podcasting platform. Any little bit helps, and I'm so thankful for those of you who go out of your way to do any small thing.
thanks so much for listening, and on to the show
[00:01:00]
Michael Zarick: Hello, my name is Michael Zarick, and this is Third Space Indy. In 1989, a man named Ray Oldenburg wrote a book called The Great Good Place, and in this book he coined the term the third place. This describes somewhere outside of your home and outside of your work that you can go be with others, be yourself, and build community.
So I've made it my goal to find people all over Indianapolis, and today Speedway, who are doing their very best to build those types of spaces. Which brings me to my guest today. This is somebody who has, quite literally gone on multiple quests, and is reaching the end of her second one. and I'm fortunate enough to have gotten her on my show to be a part of that quest.
She's also a professional emcee, and professional, by her own admission, menace all around town, which brings me to today's guest, Jennifer Magley. How you doing?
Jennifer Magley: I'm doing [00:02:00] amazing. Thank you. That was, like, such a fantastic intro. And thank you for making this show. I, I mean it. It's something that's so important here in Indy, being able to find your safe space.
Michael Zarick: Mm-hmm.
Jennifer Magley: You know?
Michael Zarick: Definitely.
Jennifer Magley: We're in my safe space today.
Michael Zarick: And we're gonna talk about that.
Jennifer Magley: All up in it.
Michael Zarick: but before that, for anybody who may not know who you are, would you talk about yourself? Tell me what you are... What you are. Who you are, what you're about, and what you do.
Jennifer Magley: Yes. So I am just a middle-aged, Midwestern, melanated mom from the middle of nowhere who decided to try to land on the biggest bro sports show in the world for a full year.
That was season one, Stooge Quest. And now in season two, working to land on 100 stages in 365 days. Former pro athlete, division one head coach. I've been every woman, but I'm not saying I've done it well.
Michael Zarick: That's, that's funny. Yeah. So we are at Borage, uh, which I have been to a number of times, single digit number of times, [00:03:00] but it's excellent every time I come.
But you mentioned that this is a safe space for you. I always ask, uh, my guests to suggest somewhere that they feel comfortable-
Jennifer Magley: Yes ...
Michael Zarick: um, in whatever way that means for them, and you've mentioned this place. So, um, what about Borage, like, popped out at you when I asked you that question?
Jennifer Magley: Yes. For me, Borage is a little bit like an island, as I live in Brownsburg, and there's not a ton of locally owned spots.
And for me, when I walk in and I see that everyone is welcome here, well, nearly everyone is welcome here. Yeah,
Michael Zarick: I've seen the sign.
Jennifer Magley: If, if you're part of that ICE initiative, maybe not so much. This might not be a spot for you. But I find this to be, like, my place. So I come here to celebrate, I come here to grieve.
I come here literally multiple times a week. I feel like, oh, I'm, I'm in the neighborhood. I can come and be safe here.
Michael Zarick: Mm.
Jennifer Magley: And that's, like, for real, for real.
Michael Zarick: You mentioned grieving.
Jennifer Magley: Yes.
Michael Zarick: Um, what, uh, what about Borage- Oh, my
Jennifer Magley: gosh ...
Michael Zarick: is, was the place for grieving?
Jennifer Magley: Yeah. No, I [00:04:00] know. And I can, I can come in and, and feel my true feels.
Mm. So if I am in- like really disappointed, I can come in and be fine with that and like show like, "Yeah, I'm having a little bit of a harder day." Yeah,
Michael Zarick: definitely.
Jennifer Magley: And I think that's hard to do in a public space.
Michael Zarick: Uh-huh. Absolutely.
Jennifer Magley: Yeah.
Michael Zarick: I, I, um- There was a pizza place I've mentioned before in Arkansas called Pizzeria Ruby.
Jennifer Magley: Aw.
Michael Zarick: And when I first got my job that I was laid off from before starting this podcast, I had, like, one of the worst work days of my life. My bosses recognized it, and they, like, gave me some money to, like, go to that pizza place- Aw ... or just, like, wherever. Um, and I just remember going in feeling terrible-
Jennifer Magley: Yes
Michael Zarick: and then had a couple beers, a beautiful pizza, and just, leaving feeling just, like, incredible. And, like, the power of both food and a space I was comfortable in just to, heal you but in the most literal sense of the word, like, was really, something memorable for me. is that that experience you've had here?
Jennifer Magley: Yeah, completely. Like, I do some [00:05:00] of my best scheming and scamming here. I came here right after I posted the first video where I dressed as the host of the Bro Sports show. Um, I came here, and I was, like, shaking. I was nervous. Like, what is this gonna be? This is a whole huge brand that films here in town.
And I came here after, like, not hearing anything for a full year. So it's definitely, like, the highs and lows. This is the, this is the place that has my heart. Yeah. Zoe and Josh do a great job. I mean, they come from huge pedigree, uh, in the kitchen, but I think, like, the heart of it, like, it doesn't feel too cool for school here.
Michael Zarick: Yeah, absolutely.
Jennifer Magley: You know what- Very humble ... I'm talking about, yeah.
Michael Zarick: You know that wall over there is, like, all art from his grandmother's house?
Jennifer Magley: Oh, I didn't know that. Yeah. That's beautiful.
Michael Zarick: Um-
Jennifer Magley: I love it.
Michael Zarick: Yeah, so it's, like, a very, like, it's a very them space.
Jennifer Magley: Mm-hmm.
Michael Zarick: so you live in Brownsburg. Yeah. And I, uh, we're, we're talking about this.
I would say that normally I would not... I, I try to focus on Marion County.
Jennifer Magley: Yes.
Michael Zarick: Um, but as somebody who I [00:06:00] recognize as very involved with Indianapolis in your work, in your content, as an individual, how do you feel about both your relationship with Brownsburg and your relationship with Indianapolis and, like, how do those things commingle?
How do they separate? You know what I'm-
Jennifer Magley: Yeah ...
Michael Zarick: getting at.
Jennifer Magley: Yeah. I think that first off, I a lot of times lie and just say I'm from Indianapolis to people- ... that are not from Indy.
Michael Zarick: My wife is, my wife is from Brownsburg, and she just says Indy most-
Jennifer Magley: Okay, yeah, and so, like, when you leave the state and people are like, "Where are you from?"
"I'm from Indy." It's easier. Y- you know, you don't have to explain, oh, Brownsburg, kind of a suburb of Indianapolis. Yeah. But I relate to Indianapolis kind of the way I relate to all the other counties is that if we lived in Los Angeles, you'd be driving over two hours a day just to get anywhere. So for me, I know this sounds awful, but they're ki- not that they're all the same, but they're all the same in access to me.
So I'm happy to... Oh, I consider d- [00:07:00] myself to be a part of all the communities, but maybe that's a God complex thing. That's- I'm everywhere.
Michael Zarick: That's funny. Yeah. Uh, so- In what, like, ways, I guess a question I have is, uh, speaking on Brownsburg, this is something, a place that, um, by my own observation over my sh- 12-year relationship with my wife, both as a friend and a, a lover, I guess- Lover
lover. Um, is a place that has, like, really developed and, like, become, revitalized in a lot of ways. Um, as you've lived there, how long have you lived in Brownsburg?
Jennifer Magley: We've been there five years.
Michael Zarick: Okay. As you've lived there, have you seen a shift in, in culture or anything like that that you've found interesting?
Jennifer Magley: Yeah, I am the shift. Like, I am the culture.
Michael Zarick: I am the shift.
Jennifer Magley: I am the m- the moment in Brownsburg, and what, what I mean is our new build neighborhood, if there's, like, 35 kids at the bus stop, I promise you 30 of them [00:08:00] seem to be Brown in some way. This is my first time that I have ever had Black neighbors.
It's the first time I've ever had neighbors that were internationally married from, like, two different Spanish-speaking coun- uh, countries. I literally, as somebody who, again, as like a Black suburban, a melanated suburban person with a white dad, didn't have that kind of diversity growing up. So when I say, like, we are that shift, literally at school it's so cool for our kids.
Like, we have two young boys, they're, they're Black with a white grandpa. They're not the only Black boys in class. There's so many. So it's really unique for them to get to experience that kind of diversity, and they're not known as, like, you know, Black Blake or whatever.
Michael Zarick: I mean, you can even see that, like, at, at a more, like, simplistic level, just, like, the restaurants that have popped up, like-
Jennifer Magley: We're getting there.
Bit by bit. Yeah. We got Tempest. It's a new coffee shop on, on kind of our main stretch. But I, you know, in relations, in relationship to Indianapolis, what I love about Indy is how, [00:09:00] how liberal it is in, in regards to everything, you know? It's just more open.
Michael Zarick: Mm-hmm.
Jennifer Magley: And I feel like Brownsburg may be opening up, but it's, it's, it's still kind of too early to say.
Mm-hmm. Racially, ethnically, it is open. I know that for a fact.
Michael Zarick: Yeah. So you may not have, um... Sorry to shift- Yeah ... back towards Indianapolis a little bit. So you may not have necessarily found, um, success getting on... Are you calling it The Bro Sports Show?
Jennifer Magley: I've been calling it The Bro Sports Show. Are
Michael Zarick: we, are we allowed to
Jennifer Magley: call it
Michael Zarick: by name?
Jennifer Magley: I mean, totally. Okay. They haven't, like, sent me a letter or anything, so.
Michael Zarick: Okay. Well,
Jennifer Magley: so The Pat McAfee Show. It's, it's The Pat McAfee Show. So- He's a country singer now.
Michael Zarick: Is he? Is that true?
Jennifer Magley: I swear to
Michael Zarick: God. I don't know that.
Jennifer Magley: Yeah, he, he had this song and I was like- I
Michael Zarick: am out of the loop ...
Jennifer Magley: yo, first song that dropped Pitbull in a mugshot.
My, my good brotheren. I,
Michael Zarick: I can't.
Jennifer Magley: Pitbull in a mugshot. Is that
Speaker: I got a pit bull and a mugshot. Putting cliches up in a tough spot.
Michael Zarick: the real-
Jennifer Magley: Yes, I did my research ... I need [00:10:00] to
Michael Zarick: look this up.
Jennifer Magley: There were less than 1,000
Michael Zarick: listeners- I'm gonna drop a little 10-second clip
Jennifer Magley: here ... within 48 hours
Michael Zarick: so, you may not necessarily have found success... Well, let's set the stage, so let's set the stooge.
Jennifer Magley: Hey, set the-
Michael Zarick: Um, . So Stooge Quest was you attempting, as somebody who has experience in professional sports- Mm-hmm ... both as an athlete, but as somebody who has been there from a, um... Well, your, your mother is also involved in professional sports also.
Jennifer Magley: Yeah, first woman to own a, a pro sports league, and it's a men's league,
Michael Zarick: so.
So you, your life has been integrated in sports wholeheartedly in- Yeah ... mul- uh, multi- multiple facets. so you're very qualified to go on a show like The Pat McAfee Show to talk to him about the things he talks about. Um, and the Stooge Quest was your sort of audition, I guess, would be- Yeah ... how, what was the
Jennifer Magley: framing about- I mean, it's kind of like if you're Superman, it's, you know, I got to be Clark Kent for a little [00:11:00] So humble.
But really, I wanted to do what, what the bros did to see if they could recognize that we're actually the same.
Michael Zarick: Hmm.
Jennifer Magley: And, uh, and also could they take a joke? And also, someone rode their personal brand to the White House twice with the same four key verticals that, that, that makes that show popular. Mm-hmm.
You know, very much WWE, reality TV, name recognition. Um, yeah. I mean, those, those are the main things that helped someone get elected, we know who, into the White House, and now they're also have their, their finger on the pulse of the bro culture and the sports culture. So actually, what I wanted to show over that full year was I'm just like you, and that to be a sidekick on that show, you don't have to have credentials.
Michael Zarick: Hmm.
Jennifer Magley: That's the whole gag. You just have to be what they call a stooge.
Michael Zarick: Okay.
Jennifer Magley: So I wanted to show them some, a little bad behavior over a full year, that, "Hey, guys, I'm down. We're actually- See- "... we're the same." [00:12:00] It's, it's subversive, but we're the same.
Michael Zarick: Yes, yes. We're
Jennifer Magley: the same. Yeah.
Michael Zarick: So you may not have found necessarily success in...
So you completed the quest, which is that you did the thing.
Jennifer Magley: Yeah, yeah.
Michael Zarick: But you didn't necessarily get the, um, spoken outcome.
Jennifer Magley: Did not, did not get a response.
Michael Zarick: But- On the topic of, like, success-
Jennifer Magley: Mm-hmm ...
Michael Zarick: I think you have become, um... You've gained notoriety-
Jennifer Magley: Oh, that's
Michael Zarick: kind ... in Indianapolis. That's the best word I can use.
how do you feel like you have been accepted or absorbed, or whatever word you wanna use, within the- the space of Indianapolis, the community or culture or whatever?
Jennifer Magley: Yeah. I think Indianapolis is a really unique place because it's a space where everyone generally will tell you yes.
Michael Zarick: I- I agree with that.
Jennifer Magley: You know what I'm saying?
Michael Zarick: Except for a certain someone.
Jennifer Magley: It's just... But they're not from Indy, right? But yeah, like, it's everyone will say yes. Everyone will have a, have a coffee with you if you [00:13:00] don't meet them. Th- this is, you know, the such a high-rated place to do business because everyone's really open. So because of that, I've met so many wonderful people, and I have this saying that is a part of, um, Stage Quest, which is the 100 stages, is that since I don't belong anywhere, I can be everywhere, and I feel like Indy is a great example of that because the first thing that everybody asks you when you come into Indy from the outside is, "What high school did you go to?"
And-
Michael Zarick: It's a very Midwest thing ...
Jennifer Magley: you know what I mean? They, like, they wanna place you.
Michael Zarick: Wait, where are you from originally?
Jennifer Magley: Uh, Kansas, but by way- Okay ... of Florida. Okay. So we went, like, traditional, then transient, and then- Yeah ... came back around.
Michael Zarick: Well, that's a very common thing in Louisville, Kentucky also. It's like where did...
When you say, "Where did you go to school?- Where'd you go to high school ... it's "Where did you
Jennifer Magley: go to high school?" Yeah. It's the same thing, yeah. Where'd you go to school? And since I will forever be every adult's new friend- Yeah ... since I live in Indy, since I didn't go to high school with them- Mm-hmm ... I was like, "Okay, how are we gonna make the most of it?"
So I have found acceptance with a lot of different groups of people. [00:14:00] I don't know if I can say community, because I don't really know how we define community still in Indianapolis. Mm. It's still up in the air, but with a lot of different groups of people, and also I would say even groups of individuals y- 'cause what you'll see in Indy is a lot of content creators, a lot of people that are outside, out and about.
They're still individuals that are in groups.
Michael Zarick: Agreed.
Jennifer Magley: So for example, like you go to dinner, and if you see these individuals in groups together, they're not all dressed the same. They don't all have the same style. These are eagles that have decided to kinda, ah, convene-
Michael Zarick: Yeah, yeah. ...
Jennifer Magley: for a moment of community.
Michael Zarick: Yes.
Jennifer Magley: And then they fly back out. Yeah. So I don't see a lot of flock behavior-
Michael Zarick: Mm-hmm ...
Jennifer Magley: in Indy. Do you- That makes sense. What about you? Do you see
Michael Zarick: a lot of- No, that's a great... I, genuinely, that is like an excellent metaphor. It's like I know exactly what... So, we're speaking about the future, but by the time this will come out, it'll be in the past.
So you're-
Jennifer Magley: Yeah ...
Michael Zarick: soon going to be a guest on my friend Patrick Armstrong's show.
Jennifer Magley: Oh my God,
Michael Zarick: amazing. For your 100th stage. [00:15:00] Yeah. Um, and something he's personally struggling with is how does he get the people at his show to interface with each other? Which is exactly what you're talking about. Yes. Which is like there's these different subgroups that are sort of overlapping through Patrick in a way, but it's like how does he get those people to interweave?
And I think this is a, a sub ecosystem, I guess, using the, the bird metaphor- Yes ... of like the wider Indianapolis, 'cause you mentioned like what culture do we, or what, you know, community do we have. It's like, oh, we have, you know, six nonprofits that do all sorts of the same thing, but they don't really work with each other.
Right. They have, you know, all sorts of businesses that are not interwoven in a way that I think is necessarily effective. Um, this is something I actually think... Sorry f- to take up the airwaves, but- No ... um, in Northwest Arkansas- There was a syrup business. Oh, wow. Like, they just made syrup. It's called Pink House.
Um, Pink House Alchemy. Uh, and almost every coffee shop, like, sold... [00:16:00] Like, they had Pink House syrup. Um, ice cream shops would use Pink House syrup. Like, um, and then there's Onyx Coffee, which is a world-renowned coffee shop that every business down there sells Onyx Coffee. There's this, like, interweaving of the local community businesses that I don't think I personally see here.
Obviously, they sell Blue Mind here at Borage. But, um, there's something that I think is lacking in the... Even though everybody's willing to sit down and have coffee with you-
Jennifer Magley: Yes ...
Michael Zarick: it's like, how do I-
Jennifer Magley: It's that Hoosier Ho-
Michael Zarick: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Jennifer Magley: The de- decoding the Hoosier hospitality. I think that our best creators and leaders align, with tasks.
Michael Zarick: Hmm.
Jennifer Magley: So you'll see this even with summits and conferences, and anything that is requiring collaboration, the through line, in my opinion, in my experience rather, in Indy, is through a task. So we've got, like, the Super Bowl coming to town, or we've got this swimming, you know? And then we [00:17:00] all say, "Okay, we're all gonna show up for this moment."
Michael Zarick: Yeah.
Jennifer Magley: But when the moment passes, I don't think those are the same folks that are calling each other and saying, "Hey, I'm really struggling." You know, I think that showing that vulnerability is something that Hoosier hospitality doesn't do best- Hmm ... sometimes, 'cause everyone wants to just, "I got the W, I got the win," you know?
Which is so cool about failing in public for two straight years.
Michael Zarick: There's a, there's a term that has entered my life, uh, recently, um, for, from multiple angles actually, but it's the term, and I think you'll appreciate this, which is to be cringe is to be free.
Jennifer Magley: Oh, completely. Oh, cringe is... It's like, what is, what is cringe even?
Like, what does it, what does it even mean? Yeah, I, I think in my case, I experienced something so traumatic with, uh, you know, a relationship not working out, that it broke my brain and it broke my ego and my identity that now I'm free. You know? Now I'm free to be [00:18:00] cringe- Yeah ... because I'm thinking nothing could ever be like that.
Like, what, what's, what's the worst that could happen? I mean, someone with nothing to lose is really dangerous, you know?
Michael Zarick: Concerning.
Jennifer Magley: Concerning. Living in the middle of nowhere? Concerning.
Michael Zarick: So let's, um, maybe circle back to- Yeah ... the circle back. let's talk about The Stage Quest a little bit. So this is the follow-up to The Stooge Quest.
Jennifer Magley: Yes.
Michael Zarick: Is the purpose of The Stage Quest, which we're nearing the end of, and you're ahead of schedule, mind you-
Jennifer Magley: Can you believe it? Nine months and 12 days, but who's counting? I'm nine months and tw- I finished it, I will have finished it nine months, 12 days. It's basically like a overdue baby at this point.
Michael Zarick: What was the original purp- Is it just to challenge yourself?
Jennifer Magley: So to set myself free with the first season, I went micro, one brand, get one answer. And in season two, a lot of pe- some people liked it, some people hated it, season one. And so I'm like, "You know what? Run it back. You get to be the one. You get to [00:19:00] be the McAfee and decide whether or not I'm on your stage, whether I'm on your show or not."
So then, you know, I went micro, now we're macro. We're gonna go everywhere. We're gonna do everything. Literally everything, Michael. This,
Michael Zarick: this i- Uh, listen, I, okay ...
Jennifer Magley: everything, y'all. Everything.
Michael Zarick: You hosted a corn eating competition-
Jennifer Magley: Oh, my God ...
Michael Zarick: an Excel show.
Jennifer Magley: Yes.
Michael Zarick: You have-
Jennifer Magley: On ESPN2. Uh, you- Can you believe? ... have
Michael Zarick: eaten a- The ESPN The Other
Jennifer Magley: Show
Michael Zarick: shrimp cocktail. You have-
Jennifer Magley: Sold out stadium.
Michael Zarick: I just-
Jennifer Magley: Pacers-Celtics game, day after Christmas.
Michael Zarick: What is something that- Well, I guess I can't even ask that question 'cause I think all three of those are sort of surprising. But like, like what, are you surprised any longer?
Jennifer Magley: Um, you know what surprises me is the behavior of the other people who are taking this like their life depends on it. So for example, I once emceed [00:20:00] a pageant for young women and girls that was based on this con- of dis- it was based on disability. The parents were just as nasty as parents of gals that don't have disabilities.
Shocked me. I would've thought this was more about showing up, and character, and it was like, oh, no, huge criticism. It was just like
Michael Zarick: cutthroat.
Jennifer Magley: Yeah. Oh, completely. It was still pageant life, right? That's awesome. So for me, I was, I'm on stage, I'm watching all the talents and, you know, trying to gauge how other people are responding, what's supposed to be funny, what's not supposed to be funny, and that was wild.
So that opened my eyes. That surprised me. And then even the other day at the, at the Wilson's Corn Eating Competition at the Indiana State Fair, shocked. There was a woman, started cussing on stage. She was mad. She thought she should've been second place. She was pissed. Pissed. We had a situation. So that's the thing that surprises me the [00:21:00] most, is the behavior of the folks that are taking this so seriously, whereas I'm just like, "Is life really that serious?
Can I kayfabe my life away?" I- You know?
Michael Zarick: I wanna ask you about that, though, because you're historically a competitor. I, I used- You played professional tennis ... God, I used
Jennifer Magley: to be... Yes. I used to be so competitive.
Michael Zarick: So
Jennifer Magley: like-
Michael Zarick: Are you, are you actually surprised by that? Or do you feel like your mind sha- mind has shifted away from that and now it's, like, become, like, why would anyone be that serious about anything?
Jennifer Magley: I have stereotypically projected my, non-competitive nature onto people now, right? And like, I'm at the Microsoft Excel World Championships at the HyperX Arena in Las Vegas, and I'm saying to myself like, "Wait a minute, you're interviewing this guy who just got disqualified. Remember, those are actually tears in his eyes."
Like, he came from the other side of the world, whereas for me, I'm... I, I am, I will say, have self-actualized to the point of like, it's okay that I didn't win. It's okay that this thing didn't happen, but [00:22:00] that's not where people still are, than when you want something. So it's a reminder that I'm not where I used to be competitively, and so that shocks me, 'cause I'm like, "We're just here for fun."
Yeah. You know? We're here to serve the event.
Michael Zarick: Interesting.
Jennifer Magley: Forgetting about the taking the L.
Michael Zarick: Yeah. So what's the... Is there a goal of the Stage Quest?
Jennifer Magley: Yes. Uh, it was, it was, one, to show range. I wanted people to see a melanated woman in places and spaces that they've never seen. I've never seen a, a melanated woman at a shrimp cocktail eating competition, like, 'cause ain't nobody got time for that, right?
So I went like, you know, not o- not only am I gonna do it, I'm gonna win, I'm gonna microdose the sauce, I'm gonna train at the restaurants, I'm gonna-
Michael Zarick: Yeah. Do you like cocktail sauce?
Jennifer Magley: I do now. That's funny. Shout out Hughes Culinary, sponsored this show. That's funny. But yeah. Like, I definitely, I definitely wanted...
There, there's that aspect, like I want you to see me in spaces you don't see. And then secondly, yeah, it was tongue in cheek. Like, let's give the bro sports show another chance to be [00:23:00] part of this incredible cat- there's nothing but good for them in this. They can be the heroes at any point. Any point.
We've built it that way. At any point, they could be the hero and say yes, they could be the hero and say no. We're too cool for you. We're too big, no space. But the silence in that third part of it is what's made it so fun.
Michael Zarick: Yeah. This is something I'm maybe hyper fixating on. I'm genuinely interested. Like, are...
Do you care?
Jennifer Magley: It's been, it's been up and down. You know, I knew that they, I knew that I would never get on the show.
Michael Zarick: I'm more so like-
Jennifer Magley: I was so looking forward to the rejection of it. That, that was So
Michael Zarick: you just want an answer.
Jennifer Magley: Oh yeah, I just want an answer.
Michael Zarick: Because I think there's
Jennifer Magley: like- An answer would've been amazing
Michael Zarick: I guess there's the question of like, you know, if they finally say yes, are they saying it out of pity, or are they like-
Jennifer Magley: I'll take it ...
Michael Zarick: you know what I mean? Like-
You
Jennifer Magley: know those Wish kids, they take the w- they take-
Michael Zarick: That's
Jennifer Magley: crazy. I granted a wish, so I can say that. I raised the money. They're... And, and, and side note, they're going on the trips regardless when you raise the money.
But, but yes, I, if, [00:24:00] if... I don't think that brand can have shame.
Michael Zarick: Hm.
Jennifer Magley: I don't think that's how they move. I think they, they operate from the space of we are shameless. We love to have fun, and this is a collection of, of stooges, you know, just messing around- Yeah ... doing stunts, pranks, and skits. And that's why I was saying, "Hey," like, "I'm one of you guys.
I don't even need to be in the studio. I can do a stooge on the street." Like, "If you aren't ready for this, I'll be on the str- on them streets for you asking intoxicated people." Which you are doing. Yeah. You know, it's been fun. So, uh, do I wanna get on the show? Would I love an a- I would lo- number one, I'd love an answer.
That would be cool. Number two, if it was yes, how amazing. But number three, if it's not, you know, even better for the documentary- Yeah ... for the film festival. The French love a non-answer. They love a non-ending.
Michael Zarick: The, the reason I ask is 'cause I feel like this is, like, m- my patriarchy brain-
Jennifer Magley: Ah ...
Michael Zarick: working.
Jennifer Magley: Ah.
Michael Zarick: Um, are, do you feel like you're affirming [00:25:00] the patriarchy or affirming their, their power or their position by, like, seeking their approval or denying- By trying to get on the show?
Jennifer Magley: I see what I've done as more, um, parody, which is something they say they do.
Michael Zarick: Mm-hmm.
Jennifer Magley: And I would also say that they would believe that they're being subversive, but I believe what I've been doing is subversive, is that when you work in these, in the world of cliche, be a friend, tell a friend, try hard, never give up.
You know, you gotta give it all you got when you got the dog, you know? When you, when you really, when you are hugely built on Americana and phrases like that, let's put it to the test.
Michael Zarick: Yeah.
Jennifer Magley: You know? Let's see if you really bout that dog or if you really bout that underdog, 'cause I don't know how long you can be an underdog when you make $60 million a year.
Michael Zarick: Yeah. Agreed.
Jennifer Magley: Who's, who's the underdog now? This guy. That's what I think. So is it, is it funny to say, to me, it's [00:26:00] funny to knock on the boys cl- door and, and the boys club and say, like, "Come on, guys," like, "Let me in. Let me in," you know? Yeah. And I find it to be, um, unique. It's a unique situation to say, "Your show's so good, but it'd be better if I was on it," you know?
I think that's the... I think they get it. I think they get it. I don't know if they like it, but they get it, and maybe deep down they respect it. Maybe.
Michael Zarick: Let's talk about your wardrobe.
Jennifer Magley: Let's go. Wow!
Michael Zarick: I don't think I've ever seen you wear the same thing twice.
Jennifer Magley: Oh, you know-
Michael Zarick: Maybe I'm not paying enough attention
Jennifer Magley: I just rotate it. I just rotate it all around. Where,
Michael Zarick: where are these clothes coming from? This is not-
Jennifer Magley: Some-
Michael Zarick: This is like- ...
Jennifer Magley: lovely- ...
Michael Zarick: one of one.
Jennifer Magley: Probably some lovely child
Michael Zarick: made this. Let's describe it- You know, it- ... because this is an audio format. Yeah. So- Oh, oh ... it's kind of like Adidas- Oh, I didn't realize that
well, it's both.
Jennifer Magley: Yeah, yeah. There's
Michael Zarick: some Adidas- So it's like Adidas tracksuit pants-
Jennifer Magley: Green ...
Michael Zarick: but with frilly-
Jennifer Magley: Yeah ... uh- We got a lot of ruffles going on ... bell-bottoms. Some bell-bottoms, and then a top that could also be a dress, royal blue. What do I got? Oh, some acrylic [00:27:00] earrings, blue. I mean, I look like I could have...
Like, I, 'cause you know I introduced the Circle City Stomper Clown Band- Mm ... at the fair. It wasn't hard for me to find something to match those guys. Like, it's their 50th anniversary. They've performed at the fair 46 times. Couldn't have been more honored, and when they showed up, it was kind of like who wore it best-
Michael Zarick: Yeah
Jennifer Magley: between the two of us.
Michael Zarick: Definitely. Did they give you an honorary nose or something?
Jennifer Magley: Well, well, I, I don't think they perform in noses, but they- Oh ... definitely gave me kinda like a clock that tea. That's funny. A clown clock that tea.
Michael Zarick: That's funny. So where, what's the- You know ... what's the source of, of this? I just feel like I'm always-
Jennifer Magley: Yeah
Michael Zarick: impressed by what you're showing up in. Like,
Jennifer Magley: what is, what is, what is the deal? I'm a big method dresser, so usually, like, when I go to milk the cow competitively tomorrow at the fair, I will be wearing... I've been practicing
Michael Zarick: on a goat at Contra Berry. I, I saw your video. I saw the video- ... of you milking the goat, and I was like, "She will literally do anything."
Jennifer Magley: I will literally... Yeah. I've been, I've been doing this in my sleep. I will wear stars and stripes [00:28:00] overalls with, like, red pearls and a... So I am more like, I, 'cause I, I don't feel like there's anything as, as personal style. Like, I don't believe in personal style. I believe in just dressing for the moment or the vibe or the energy.
And so yeah, just, like, how many times can I throw these things together and then rotate them? Okay. Oh, I was emceeing this. Okay, can't wear that. You get in the back of the line. But everybody gets a chance in my closet. Everybody gets that business. I'm like, "It's your day. You gotta go to work today."
Michael Zarick: We...
I've had this conversation with my wife before. I'm like, "When are you ever gonna wear that?" She goes, "It'll come up." Yeah. Don't you know? It'll, it'll happen.
Jennifer Magley: And I'm just gonna make that moment happen. Yeah. Yeah. I'm, I'm making it happen. I'm wearing all my wigs, all my jewelries. As long as it's not wearing me, we are good to go.
'Cause I am the wig police. If you got a bad wig and you're an actor, if you got a bad wig and you're nor- You clock it? Yeah. Oh, my husband goes, "Wee-oo, wee-oo" 'Cause he knows I'm about to go off. And I'm not... I don't know.
Michael Zarick: You're like the... So the, like, there's a common thing with, like, graphic designers where they, like, see, [00:29:00] um, TypeScript in movies-
and, like, have panic attacks. You're like that with wigs.
Jennifer Magley: Like Avatar.
Michael Zarick: Yeah. The
Jennifer Magley: Avatar font.
Michael Zarick: Exactly.
Jennifer Magley: Yeah, I am that way with wigs, 'cause I don't mind if I can see your lace. It just needs to be like... It needs to be a good wig, especially on the guys, 'cause they're gluing it on right now. But there's a l- a lot of the guys that I love, older, older white guys.
Everybody's wearing wigs. Everybody's spraying the hair on. More power to you, but don't come around me in a movie. Yeah. You got budget. You're a full production. How's my wig? That was the first thing I said when I saw you, was, "Great hair."
Michael Zarick: I'm kidding.
Jennifer Magley: And if you don't have hair either, that's fine. Shine that bad boy up, you know?
Michael Zarick: I had a friend- Rock it ... uh, who had such a shiny bald head that he would wax it matte so it didn't hurt your eyes.
Jennifer Magley: Mat- I have never
Michael Zarick: even heard- I'm not... It's a good... He made it less shiny.
Jennifer Magley: He got that, he got that Vin Diesel treatment. Yes. That's amazing. I love it.
Michael Zarick: We're gonna move on to what I call the canned questions.
Jennifer Magley: All right, let's go.
Michael Zarick: Um, just basically [00:30:00] questions I got loaded in the can Third Space Indy is sponsored by City Rising.
Jennifer Magley: Ooh.
Michael Zarick: City Rising is a social impact studio. Most recently they implemented an eviction data dashboard that looks to highlight and reduce the impact of the over 30,000 evictions, mostly affecting Black and Latina women Indianapolis faces every year.
Jennifer Magley: Mm.
Michael Zarick: Learn more at cityrising.org. City Rising
has asked a question, which is what is a third space to you?
Jennifer Magley: To me?
Michael Zarick: Yeah. You can answer it however you like.
Jennifer Magley: Yeah. Third space to me is kinda like Cheers. I'm old enough to know that show. You know, they come in and they're like, "Jennifer, Norm." That's, yeah, third space is sometimes you wanna go. Do you know how-
Michael Zarick: Nope.
Jennifer Magley: Where everybody knows your name. I,
Michael Zarick: I just know- ... there are people who listen to this show-
Jennifer Magley: I love that you said, "Nope."
Michael Zarick: There are people who listen to this show who will message me about this.
Jennifer Magley: [00:31:00] I hope so.
Michael Zarick: I just wanna-
Jennifer Magley: They're gonna be like, "How do... Yeah, you're not an elder millennial then."
Michael Zarick: I'm 30.
Jennifer Magley: O- Okay. I'm significantly- I'm,
Michael Zarick: I'm a, I'm on...
I consider myself a zillennial, as in like on the other end.
Jennifer Magley: No, definitely. Yeah, like a Cheers space where you walk in and people know who you are, and I think that's what everybody wants, so that's a third space to me.
Michael Zarick: Do you have a space other than Borage that fits this bill?
Jennifer Magley: Unfortunately, no. I have, I have spaces where I love the food, and the service is great, and the people are nice, but nowhere where I would come in and be like, "So, keep telling me that story about what happened to your daughter last time I was here."
You know?
Michael Zarick: I have a couple of questions.
Jennifer Magley: Yeah.
Michael Zarick: Have you c- let's assume Brownsburg is Indianapolis. Has that been your entire Indianapolis journey?
Jennifer Magley: No. I started off in Fishers. Hm. I lived off of a-
Michael Zarick: I'm so sorry ...
Jennifer Magley: a street called Deception Pass which was ironic.
Michael Zarick: Deception
Jennifer Magley: Pass? [00:32:00] Considering
Michael Zarick: Oh my God ...
Jennifer Magley: considering I learned that my whole life was fake, that was pretty wild.
And then I moved into, like, a house. My whole life changed in Fishers. And then I was like, "I gotta get out of here." Moved to Carmel and lived in Carmel. Felt very bougie, felt very cool, had wonderful amenities, and thought I was in the best school, and then met my person, and then we moved to Brownsburg.
Okay. So I li- and I am, I am one of the weirdos that will meet you anywhere around Central Indiana for coffee. Most people are locked into where they live. "Oh, I live in Broad Ripple. Oh, I live downtown." Mm-hmm. "Oh, I li-" you know. They're not gonna leave their area.
Michael Zarick: Yeah.
Jennifer Magley: And so I have been to nearly every spot, uh, there is to go to.
Yeah. And this is ... kind of found my way home here in Speedway.
Michael Zarick: this is related to a que- actually, I'll ask this question and then we'll get, circle back to this. Um, so the follow-up to the previous question is, is there a third space or place that has existed for you previously that no longer does?
Jennifer Magley: Public Greens.
Michael Zarick: Oh, in Broad Ripple?
Jennifer Magley: Oh, that used to be my spot. I,
Michael Zarick: I know so many people who [00:33:00] love that spot.
Jennifer Magley: That used to be- It's like- Like, I mean, uh, 10 years ago. I, I know towards the end it changed a little bit, but we did, like, yoga on there. I used to raise a lot of money, and I say that because I did. I'm very proud of that.
For the two years I was on, um, the Patachou Foundation board, that's now A Longer Table. Mm-hmm. So they used to have First Friday at the farms at that spot. They used to have a urban garden right across from the Monon with bees.
Michael Zarick: They just tore that out, by the way.
Jennifer Magley: See? Now that just breaks my heart. That is messed up.
It was so, it was so messed up. So Public Greens used to be the, the spot where everyone knew my name. Yeah. And I knew their names too. Yeah. I think that's also so important.
Michael Zarick: So over the course of your Indianapolis journey, Fishers, Carmel, Brownsburg- What do you think the failure of your environment is to...
Or maybe, I, I don't wanna put it on yourself 'cause I do think it is a failure of your environment, not you. Um, like, why don't you think you've found that space?
Jennifer Magley: [00:34:00] Money.
Michael Zarick: Mm.
Jennifer Magley: I think that there's still not enough money running through Indianapolis as a whole, and a willingness to spend/invest that money. I see it in events.
Every event in town is a charitable event, which is fine but, you know, go to Chicago, go to New York, there's events for the sake of the fun, you know, for the love of the game. So there is a little bit of Hoosier, Hoosier-ness that feels to have fun means you still need to give back, and I think that mentality limits the purchase of art.
It limits events. It limits people saying, "Let me take a risk and create a space, uh, for folks to come to." Because they're like, "Oh, they probably got T-Rex arms. They're not gonna reach down in those pockets." Unless it's going, you know, to Riley Hospital- Yeah ... or unless it's going to something else. So I, that's what I would say the failure is.
Still not enough money, not enough headquarters downtown and otherwise, and willingness to say, "Here you go. Let me stroke that check." Yeah. "Let me sponsor that [00:35:00] show."
Michael Zarick: Yeah.
Jennifer Magley: You know. And so that's, that's how I see it.
Michael Zarick: I think that's a really interesting observation. along that same line, You said something, Elno?
Uh, brain
Jennifer Magley: health This happened to me right before my stand-up comedy special.
Michael Zarick: Oh, wait, how did
Jennifer Magley: that go, by the way? I got so, uh, sold out. It was amazing. Standing room only. And right before I went on, um, my whole 30-minute set, which actually was a 55-minute set all scripted, just left my head. And I thought, "What the hell?"
I got overstimulated and, and I'm learning that happens to me
When it's noise, when there's noise, that's when I get like, "What was I about to say?"
Michael Zarick: Mm-hmm.
Jennifer Magley: But l- luckily Thad McKee, he opened for me. I, I told him, "If I forget my line, I'm just gonna say line or Thad, what are we talking about?" And it happened twice.
Michael Zarick: That is kind of funny.
Jennifer Magley: It was amazing. Yeah. And nobody really picked it up 'cause they were drinking but he saved my life. He saved my life with that. And 'cause I'd never done stand-up comedy before.
Michael Zarick: Yeah, definitely.
Jennifer Magley: So, you know.
Michael Zarick: It's like, that's hard.
Jennifer Magley: 55-minute set. They laughed. Um,
Michael Zarick: the, the thought came back to me- Yeah
which is that, [00:36:00] um, I thought, so this past weekend, um, there was a large amount of flooding throughout Indianapolis. Oh,
Jennifer Magley: yeah.
Michael Zarick: Um, my neighborhood is Warfleigh, which is adjacent to Broad Ripple. So people were reaching out to me being like, "Are you safe?" Um- Mm ... which I, like, there was no-
Jennifer Magley: That's wonderful ...
Michael Zarick: uh, issue happening What I found really intriguing, um, both in a pleasant way and sort of like a I-wish-this-were-different way, was that as I walked around to, like, look at the river or look when there...
look at the water of... that was coming out of the ground-
Jennifer Magley: Yeah ...
Michael Zarick: um, all of this type of stuff, I would encounter people who were effectively my neighbors, lived within, a quarter or less mile of me, and would have a conversation. And I was like, "Why does it take a, a environmental disaster for me to, um, have this very pleasant interaction with people who live single-digit number [00:37:00] of doors down the street from me?"
Um, and when you talk about the lack of investment in just creating community spaces or just things for fun, I think that is, like, so... it rings so true to me. Mm-hmm. Especially after making that observation within the past few days. it's like I, I think we get caught up in this, like, everything has to be for a purpose.
Jennifer Magley: Yeah. There's literally no w-... Maybe it's just a lack of whimsy- ... in Indy.
Michael Zarick: Yeah.
Jennifer Magley: But, you know, um, I... and the way that... my favorite quote, uh, from s- is, "I criticize by creation, not by finding fault." It's by Cicero, whose first name was Marcus, which I find to be very strange just 'cause, like, we don't say Marcus. But for what this look...
how do I bring whimsy to, to everyday life? It's when I go and I get to emcee, uh, which is set to happen, the Indianapolis Monumental Marathon, 15,000 people, for the third time this year. I'm not gonna [00:38:00] show up with a, like, tracksuit on. I'm gonna come and I'm gonna be whimsical. I'm gonna be what I wanna see.
And, and yeah, you might feel a little bit more like it's The Hunger Games as you cross, cross the finish line, but I definitely learned that everyone turns their head to the right when they vomit ... instead of the left. And that's what you learn being at the finish line of a mini marathon and a full marathon.
So I think that's another part of it, is, you know, I'm putting a lot of blame on the businesses, but maybe, maybe us as Indiana folks could be a little more whimsical ourselves, and it starts, it starts with little stuff like that. You know, just showing up as your true self and, and throwing caution and vomit to the wind.
Yeah. You know? I don't know.
Michael Zarick: That's crazy. I'm interested in your husband. This is-
Jennifer Magley: Oh my gosh. He's the best ...
Michael Zarick: um, y- every single Instagram post you make, you tag your husband. He has a private account. I've looked. So I can't even see him.
Jennifer Magley: Dead.
Michael Zarick: Um-
Jennifer Magley: Dead. He looks like Clark Kent. I know he's a white
Michael Zarick: guy.
Jennifer Magley: He looks like Clark Kent.[00:39:00]
And the, and the joke was, yeah, Clark Kent in the street, Superman in the sheets, yeah. Oh. Sorry. So sorry to our youths.
Michael Zarick: Um-
Jennifer Magley: Our youths
Michael Zarick: What's his name? Sorry.
Jennifer Magley: Rob.
Michael Zarick: Rob?
Jennifer Magley: Yep.
Michael Zarick: Um- Is, are you... So the thing, the joke that I had in my head, which is that- ... you are tagging him in your, um, in your Instagram posts almost as a way to, like, ward off evil.
You're like,
Jennifer Magley: uh-
Michael Zarick: Yes.
Jennifer Magley: You're like- You so get me. Yeah.
Michael Zarick: I'm like, "Oh, it's like I,
Jennifer Magley: This is 100% accurate.
Michael Zarick: Really? I was like- Yes ... this is like, you're like, "I'm a woman on the internet who's, like, fairly attractive," and you're like, "Here's my husband."
Jennifer Magley: Oh, no. It's to ward off other women who think that I am a threat.
Michael Zarick: Oh.
Jennifer Magley: To their husbands. I'm dead. Yes. It's not even for the men. That's so funny. Because I give off so- such BDE, you know?
Michael Zarick: Oh, okay. Yeah, big dick energy.
Jennifer Magley: Yes. I
Michael Zarick: give- Got you. I was like, "
Jennifer Magley: What is that?" Yeah, I actually give off BVE, but everyone thinks that's a disor- you know, something you can catch. [00:40:00] But, um,
Michael Zarick: That's hilarious
Jennifer Magley: I, yeah, that, that no one actually ever has, like, slid into my DMs or send me an unwanted photo. This is literally for the wives that, that think that I am, want their man or I am interested. Because I am in a lot of spaces where I'm having coffee with men, I'm having dinners with men. It is not even a thing.
I'm one of the guys in my head. And so it's like, women, never fear. I have a husband. is- And he He, yeah, he's, yeah. And he just accepts the collabs or doesn't. Um, and he's, I mean, he literally, Michael sent me flowers saying, uh, "It's the final countdown. So proud of you. Can't wait to see you hit stage 100," yesterday, delivered to the house.
This is the kind of man he is. Any time I did anything, you know, I said, "Oh, I g- I'm getting ready to create a fake tampon scandal- ... for the Pat McAfee Show that, that their faces were on all these tampons. I'm gonna put it, I'm gonna do a fake, I don't know, I'm gonna... Then that, that fake CEO, which is me, I'm gonna put it [00:41:00] on a b- on a fake show, like I'm apologizing to him, and then I'm gonna put it on a billboard downtown with sound.
Do you think that's too far?" And I go report it in as a newscaster. He said, "Not far enough." He's like your biggest champion He is. We call ourselves the Disgusting Brothers. Which is a, which is a reference to the Succession, uh, the show on HBO. And, and I don't think that that's what people realize is this is my co-creator.
This is my co-collaborator. He's just a COO of a paper company, and can't be about that life, but he's definitely my-
Like, he's, he's like- ... my
stylist- Wait ... my collaborator, my everything.
Michael Zarick: Are you, are you married to Michael from The Office?
Jennifer Magley: I, yeah. Yeah, that's- That's his favorite show. Okay. That was his comfort show when he was, whenever he was stressed out, he would weep to that show.
Michael Zarick: That's crazy.
Jennifer Magley: Yeah. He's laugh. He's like, "All right, let's just turn it on." I hear, I hear that's a thing. Everybody, The Office is like their emotional support dog. People love that show. But yeah. I can't
Michael Zarick: do that, but I-
Jennifer Magley: But you, you hit it on the head. You're the first person- I- ... to really get it.
Michael Zarick: I noticed that.
Jennifer Magley: To get [00:42:00] it.
Michael Zarick: I was like, "She's doing this for a reason." Oh, yeah. There's like... Uh, on that same, like, line of thought-
Jennifer Magley: Yeah ...
Michael Zarick: um, I actually... So someone, a good friend of mine, Lily Groot. Sh- hi, Lily. You listen. she said, like, "Michael, I really like listening to your podcast because you primarily talk to women."
Jennifer Magley: Mm.
Michael Zarick: Um, and a lot of that actually, I think, is a flaw of mine, is that I actually struggle to talk to men.
Jennifer Magley: Interesting.
Michael Zarick: Do you feel... You said, "I'm one of the boys." Yeah. You make a reference, you call yourself him, you give yourself big dick energy. Yes. Do you feel like- As somebody in your position, do you struggle to talk with women, or like-
Jennifer Magley: I did.
Yeah. I did. I had to learn how to speak to women, and that came in the form of a pink Cadillac. Are you familiar with- No ... pink Cadillac lore?
Michael Zarick: No.
Jennifer Magley: Well, a pink Cadillac is what's driven by the most successful women who sell Mary Kay, and Mary Kay is a home-based business. They would never say they are an MLM.
Of course. But multi-level marketing. Yeah. But yeah, it's a home-based business, [00:43:00] and I saw a woman in a pink Cadillac after my years and years of being antisocial, and I was like, "Oh my God, she's so amazing." And she taught me everything I know about being likable for women. And now I read books, and before I go to their conferences, I read what, you know, what's on the Jenna Bush book list and the Reese Witherspoon, and I read all that to understand what are the masses of women loving right now because I'm not always connected to that.
I don't always have my finger on the pulse of that. Yeah. Which is wild, 'cause you see me. You... I've mastered it. I've got Lavish Lunch, and Power Lunch, and women's lunches, and women's business. Mm-hmm. So if anybody out there is nervous, "How can I... You know, I'm an introvert. How can you be likable? How can you...
"There's books. I just... It's a skill for me. It's not innate.
Michael Zarick: Mm.
Jennifer Magley: I've learned how to be likable- Yeah ... with women.
Michael Zarick: No, I agree. I, I just remember... This is a story I like to tell. , When I was a freshman in college, my, uh, we had, like, it was [00:44:00] like community events. Your RA set it up- Yeah ... or whatever. And there was a thing where we were, like, painting pumpkins for October, Halloween.
And I, like, sat down next to this woman. Her name was... I remember her name was Alivia with an A.
Jennifer Magley: Oh, wow.
Michael Zarick: Don't ever spell your name that way. Um, just a very beautiful girl.
Jennifer Magley: Yeah.
Michael Zarick: Um, and I just remember, like, sitting down and talking to her and just, like, painting a pumpkin. And we left, and my RA was like, "Oh my God, Michael.
How did you, how did you sit next to Alivia? She's so hot. She's so cool. Like, how did you talk to her?" I was like, "Well," I was like, "She's a person." I was like, I was like, "I just, like, talked to her like a, like a human being." Um, and I, I... Like, it's funny that you say it's a skill 'cause I think there's, like, there is, like-
a learning curve of maybe, like, understanding that, uh, women have autonomy also. Like... They, they
Jennifer Magley: do have autonomy, but, you know, as a fellow woman too, I think motive is a really big thing- Mm-hmm ... and a lack of clarity. And I think you don't hear a lot of guys say, like, "Oh, nice outfit."
Michael Zarick: Mm.
Jennifer Magley: Right? They're, the [00:45:00] nuance of like, "Mm- This little up and down situation.
I'm not great with sarcasm. I'm not great with gray. Every time someone insults me, oh my gosh, this would probably be my hugg- my husband's biggest complaint. I get a, I would get like hate mail or hate comments, and I go, "But they ju- they s- they said I was doing a good job, though." And I like... He's like, "No, they're being sarcastic."
And I just miss it. Yeah. I don't even understand that. I'm only looking for, "Oh, well you have a lot of energy." I latch onto that part. Yeah. They're like, "Well, you have a lot of energy. It's just that you..." And I only see positive. So I think that women sometimes have more nuances that men don't, and that's the specific part that I struggled with-
Michael Zarick: Mm
Jennifer Magley: was the- And
Michael Zarick: that's why you like men, 'cause they're very straightforward.
Jennifer Magley: The simpleton-ness?
Michael Zarick: Yeah. You're like, "Oh, these guys, they're great."
Jennifer Magley: These guys are so basic, you know? That's funny. Yeah. Um. They would agree. Not you, but they would. They would. I know what you're saying. They would, they would [00:46:00] agree. I know
Michael Zarick: I failed to say this up until now. So the first time I encountered you, and I didn't know who you were-
Jennifer Magley: Uh-oh ...
Michael Zarick: I don't even remember if I heard your name during the event.
Jennifer Magley: Yeah.
Michael Zarick: You're so scared. I don't know
Jennifer Magley: why. I know. I, I always hope it's good, 'cause if it's not, I'm like, "I get it. I
Michael Zarick: get it. I get it." I think it's po- Okay, actually, I will say I kind of associate it with a negative memory, but I, it's not-
Jennifer Magley: That's fine.
Michael Zarick: But I associate you specifically with a positive aspect of it. So-
Jennifer Magley: Okay
Michael Zarick: the first time I encountered you was last year at a charity event, which was Dress For Success.
Jennifer Magley: Okay. Okay.
Michael Zarick: For... What's it called?
Jennifer Magley: Uh- The
Michael Zarick: Dress-
Jennifer Magley: the- ... Stepping Out In Style- Stepping Out In
Michael Zarick: Style ... was the event. For Dress For Success- For Dress
Jennifer Magley: For Success ... is
Michael Zarick: the organization.
Jennifer Magley: Yes, at JW Marriott.
Michael Zarick: the reason, I'll tell you why I associate it with negative. Uh-huh. Because I, it was so crazy to me to go to an event that is so supportive of women.
Jennifer Magley: Mm-hmm.
Michael Zarick: And I think that organization specifically is actually excellent and they do great work. But when you go to an organization like that and their charity event is sponsored by, um - I, it's
Jennifer Magley: coming.
I know [00:47:00] it's coming ... uh, Shein.
Michael Zarick: Shein. The
Jennifer Magley: She- the
Michael Zarick: Shein Foundation. No. I'm like, "Oh yeah, we're doing, uh..." It's like, "We support women by being sponsored by this- ... this slave labor organization." Uh, um,
that's like something- Well,
Jennifer Magley: first of all, all my gowns were custom. Custom made in America by a designer, not Shein related.
Michael Zarick: Yeah, yeah. I was- And, uh, but, but- I was just like, do you know what I'm saying though?
Jennifer Magley: But that was intentional because I, I didn't wanna wear any of the stuff. Now, I didn't know that Shein had such a presence in, is it Whitestown or Whitesville?
Michael Zarick: No, I didn't know that. I had no idea.
Jennifer Magley: And
Michael Zarick: that- Oh, are you mean up
Jennifer Magley: north? Yes. Oh, yeah. That was the local connection, is that they've got a huge warehouse factory there, and supposedly are giving back to the community in a really big way. So the folks that live in that area, that's where they go to work. The way that it was kind of massaged for their brand purposes also made me think, "Well, the people that we're serving can't afford anything better or [00:48:00] higher or made differently, so this is maybe what our clients that we serve, they're purchasing these items so they can get ready for their job interview, so they can do it."
And I think, "Okay, like interesting." But at the same time
Michael Zarick: Your face is killing me. But, but I will say-
Jennifer Magley: It's hard ...
Michael Zarick: like, other than that, like, association, I- the reason you are so memorable-
Jennifer Magley: Mm. That's kind ...
Michael Zarick: because I did remember you. Aw. When I re- when I made the connection of, like, who you were-
Jennifer Magley: Yeah ...
Michael Zarick: there are two things I remember. There was a woman who did, like, a, a circus act.
Do, do you remember her?
Jennifer Magley: Yes.
Michael Zarick: She worked at-
Jennifer Magley: Whoa, you just uncovered
Michael Zarick: a-
Jennifer Magley: Yeah ... it's about this time last year was
Michael Zarick: the- I think it's Cirque Indy. She's, like, downtown ...
Jennifer Magley: the aerial silks.
Michael Zarick: Yeah. She's dope. Also she's- That
Jennifer Magley: was,
Michael Zarick: that was- ... health as hell ...
Jennifer Magley: amazing.
Michael Zarick: Yes. Um, and then you as the emcee, the host, master of ceremonies, I think brought, uh, a certain energy that is so appealing, that is not often found at events like that
Jennifer Magley: Oh, that's kind.
Michael Zarick: Yeah. I gen- [00:49:00] genuinely like, I, I think there's, um... it's, it's hard to, like... feel like i- in a lot of ways, it's hard to make a charity event, um, exciting and fun. Um- 'Cause
Jennifer Magley: you're
Michael Zarick: gonna hit- It's also, like, a serious topic. There's a, like, there's a lot hap- and then they, like, show this really emotional video or, and all that stuff.
Oh
Jennifer Magley: my gosh, you're gonna come back out. "And next up..."
Michael Zarick: Yeah. And they're doing, like- Yeah ... emotional manipulation on you.
Jennifer Magley: Oh, and you're gonna get hit up for more money. Exactly. So you, you buy the ticket, and this is, again, Indy events. You buy any ticket in Indy, you're gonna go, but you also know you're gonna get asked three, four, five, six, seven more times once you're at the event, whether it's a silent auction, it's a live auction.
And my job for a lot of, probably the majority of these hundred stages I gotta count, is to be Santa Claus, so I gotta bring the spirit. And the problem is, if an event is too long -
Michael Zarick: You get tired ... yeah. After, you're like, "Ugh."
Jennifer Magley: The people in the audience are like, "You were cute for the first two and a half hours."
"Now girl, if you don't shut the hell up and get off that stage..." So that's why when I say- Defi- I
Michael Zarick: mean, we left [00:50:00]
Jennifer Magley: early ... it's so hard.
Michael Zarick: We left early.
Jennifer Magley: Yes. I was like, "I-" And people have been drinking since 5:00 PM. Yeah. It's such a long night, and my, so my job too, when I get these amazing opportunities to serve, is to say, "How can we cut this down by 45 minutes?"
It doesn't matter which organization it, it is in town. I wish organizations realized that people going back to Whimsy, going back to Fun, they're there for the fun. Cut the program in half and let people dance and have fun. 'Cause the only time people are dressing up in Indy is at a wedding. A wedding and a charity event.
That's it. Nobody's, nobody's doing anything
Michael Zarick: otherwise. I love that you said that.
Jennifer Magley: Isn't that the truth?
Michael Zarick: Would you, would you like to hear my theory of the world?
Jennifer Magley: I wanna hear. Tell me. Give me the juice. I'm ready for the squeeze of juice.
Michael Zarick: This is something I've said before on the podcast, which is that, and I don't know if there's a direct correlation or if it's just, like, a result or anything like this, but I think, when I think 20 years ago-
Jennifer Magley: Mm
Michael Zarick: Everyone, you know, DoorDash didn't exist.
Netflix didn't exist. Yeah. You had to go out into the world-
Jennifer Magley: Yeah ...
Michael Zarick: to experience entertainment, go buy [00:51:00] groceries, go to a restaurant. So you're very aware of how you're perceived.
Jennifer Magley: Mm.
Michael Zarick: Um, and by that, i- in a different facet in the way we are now, 'cause a lot of it is based on our phone. But there's a certain thing happening where it's like, "Okay, I'm going outside.
I should put on some clothes."
Jennifer Magley: I should brush my teeth.
Michael Zarick: I should brush my teeth. Um, and now we've reached a point where we've made everything so convenient that we've now figured out- that we've now sort of gone into this world where it's like, how do I make this as comfortable as possible for me, which is why I think there's a rise in athleisure versus what you got going on right here.
Jennifer Magley: Throwing fits, yeah. Throwing fits. Like, you're not, we're not, we're not throwing fits anymore, and I do remember that.
Michael Zarick: So I think that there's, like, um, a direct correlation between the lack of community we feel as- Mm ... a society, not just in Indianapolis, I think this is, like, a, a nationwide thing, um, and the way we dress.
Jennifer Magley: It's tough. It is a, it is a tough [00:52:00] thing. Um, I will say that the type of compliments I get indicate to me the type of person giving them. So for example , a lot of my wonderful white sisters will say, "Oh my gosh, you look so amazing. I could never wear that." Right? And you're like, "Wait a minute. What? Girl, wait, is this a compliment?
Who we talking about? What's going on?" You know? So they'll, uh, so a lot of times, like, you get those kind of moments. Another time, you'll get maybe you have on a bunch of wacky stuff. People choose just one thing. "I like those sunglasses," or, "Those shoes are amazing." And then you get the best compliments ever, which come from my melanated mamas, which are like, "Girl, you working a whole fit, head to toe."
And then they go through and name every single item- ... that you got on. So I think it's, being in Indiana, being a little bit different, you know, I think being , wearing a tank top here as a woman, when I first moved here 10 years ago, it was kind of a s- a scandal. Like, I can't believe [00:53:00] you got your shoulders out certain parts of town.
And now I feel like people are starting just now to loosen up a little bit and show a bra strap here and there.
Michael Zarick: Yeah.
Jennifer Magley: But it's, it's conservative, even in the way you dress. Lack of color, lack of texture.
Michael Zarick: Yeah.
Jennifer Magley: I think it's insides coming on the outside sometimes.
Michael Zarick: Would you say that like
As you've evolved as, like, a person-
Jennifer Magley: Mm-hmm ...
Michael Zarick: that you're- you've shown that both through personality, but also the way you dress, too?
Jennifer Magley: Yes. When I met that woman in Mary Kay, I had never even worn lipstick. Never wore makeup. And then I got to the point where I could sell 3,000 worth of dollars of mascara in an hour.
Mm-hmm. Got really good at that. And the transition and the transformation from there to who I am today, night and day. I think w- also, once I stopped taking myself so seriously, that's when I really opened up to, like, no one cares.
Michael Zarick: Yeah.
Jennifer Magley: They really don't care. Totally. I ... You know my saying. I don't know if [00:54:00] you've heard it, but I'm not coming to your funeral.
And if you're not coming to my funeral- ... why do I care what you think? You're not coming to my funeral.
Michael Zarick: That's funny. '
Jennifer Magley: Cause, like, yeah, wear whatever you want. Yeah. Nobody cares.
Michael Zarick: Uh, so w- if ... I get self-conscious about the way I dress sometimes.
Jennifer Magley: Really? Well- What do you, where do you think that comes from?
Michael Zarick: I just
Well, it's more like, um, I desire to have- See, you said not, the, you don't believe in certain, like, personal style. I desire to have a style. Mm. But I, I just don't... I think maybe it's, like, a lack of trying. That's probably also part. Like, I don't- Mm ... like, seek out clothing or anything like that. But then I'm like, well, you know, I'm dressed
Jennifer Magley: like a- I didn't even see that patch.
I love
Michael Zarick: the patch This is what my wife, my wife patched my pants. It's like that type of thing. But it's like I-
Jennifer Magley: Then, then we know where they're looking based on where the patch is.
Michael Zarick: I got sandals, you know.
Jennifer Magley: Sandals. But you're rocking the pedi. Yeah. You got the sandals out, and-
Michael Zarick: I do have a si- Also, like, have you seen the, the Chaco tan we got going
Jennifer Magley: on?
Oh my [00:55:00] gosh.
Michael Zarick: I love it. I got, I have, like, a straight Z on my, on my feet.
Jennifer Magley: I
Michael Zarick: love it. Um, I do think I have a style, which is like a crunchy Midwest guy. But I, I, I do think there's a desire to maybe dress better or, like, in a cer- You know, I am, I speak on the way that we, uh, go outside and dress while also not doing it myself.
Um, there's a, there's a level of, like, cri- um, uh, hyp- hypocrisy there. No. But also, like, I think my question is, like, how would you suggest to somebody looking to Let's use the word elevate the way that they express themselves through clothing.
Jennifer Magley: Yeah.
Michael Zarick: How would you suggest that they do that?
Jennifer Magley: If they, if they're dipping their toe into this kind of new era of what could it mean to method dress or kinda switch it up, I'd just start one small piece at a time.
A great person to follow is Wear Your Weird. They're based here in, in Carmel, Indiana. Mm-hmm. I think they're in Carmel. They ship [00:56:00] out everywhere. But it's a great follow because she started this brand to say, "Yeah, I'm... I don't care, and I'm weird and I embrace it and I own that." So I would say start, you know, put- buy that color shirt that maybe you wouldn't usually wear and, you know, start small.
Michael Zarick: Yeah.
Jennifer Magley: And see how you feel.
Michael Zarick: Well, I will say there was a time where I was like, "I really wanna be a hat guy." Oh. You know, it's funny, and I, uh, for a long time I would like put on a hat, I'm like, "This looks weird." But then I just like started- But you
Jennifer Magley: got great hair. You gotta let that hair out.
Michael Zarick: That's true. I...
No, I, I'm not even gonna deny that. I have great hair.
Jennifer Magley: I love it.
Michael Zarick: Uh, only when I wash it though. Uh, but then I like started to wear hats and I was like, oh, okay, I actually like the way I look in a hat, you know? It, and especially with my long hair I think it's sort of like it's a fun accessory. Um- Yeah ... and I...
It's funny that you say it's like just do it. It's like who, who are you- Yeah ... doing it for other than yourself? And I think that's a common thing with women too. It's like, who are you dressing up for? It's like, well, I'm dressing up for me.
Jennifer Magley: I'm dressing for me.
Michael Zarick: Yeah.
Jennifer Magley: Yes. We, we are very me. Very [00:57:00] me, me, me, me.
But also we're also dressing for the girls too. This is not, this is not for the guys. Again, when you have BVE, like this doesn't say like hubba hubba. You know? This is more like walka walka walka, uh, uh, uh, uh. You know? What I've got on right now is more clown core than, than anything you'd see on OF, you know?
Michael Zarick: That's funny.
Jennifer Magley: So yeah, definitely dr- Hey- ... dressing for my inner clown ...
Michael Zarick: there's something for everyone.
Jennifer Magley: You know?
Michael Zarick: And,
Jennifer Magley: and- Indeed.
Michael Zarick: I think someone out there is into clowns.
Jennifer Magley: Yes. Someone. It exists.
Michael Zarick: Um, Jennifer, every episode I ask a question from the previous guest.
Jennifer Magley: Ooh.
Michael Zarick: The previous guest to this episode, his name is Fred Miller, AKA MF Fred.
Are you familiar? No? He's a local content creator. You may have seen his whiteboard.
Jennifer Magley: I think... Oh, oh, yeah. I just started following him- Yeah ... literally yesterday.
Michael Zarick: Oh, okay. Yeah. He's around.
Jennifer Magley: Love it.
Michael Zarick: Good friend of mine. Uh, he asks... Actually, let me get the exact wording.
Jennifer Magley: I love that whiteboard. Does he do all the font on that?
And does he- He
Michael Zarick: draws it [00:58:00] all himself.
Jennifer Magley: That's amazing. He's got skills.
Michael Zarick: Fred asks, "What do you do in crisis?"
Jennifer Magley: Ooh. Well-
Michael Zarick: I think you're the right person to ask this question ...
Jennifer Magley: I'll tell you this: my, it seems, uh, the most crisis moment for me was in November during the election, 2024.
Michael Zarick: The, the most recent one.
Jennifer Magley: Yep. And what I did was I found out, like I said before, how, how did this happen? What were the things in common?
And I dressed to someone else to see if that strategy that worked for them and so many other folks that look like my dad and look like my husband, would the strategy work for me in attaining my goals? So in crisis, I guess I kind of became a little bit of a subversive content creator, but I don't get paid for creating content, so I just became [00:59:00] someone on a quest.
So when I'm in crisis, I quest.
Michael Zarick: Yeah.
Jennifer Magley: That sounds so cheesy, but that's what it's been. Is
Michael Zarick: there
a historical
precedent for this for you?
Jennifer Magley: I think I've, I've always- Maybe not,
Michael Zarick: like, an explicit quest, you know what I'm saying? You're not doing- Yeah, yeah ... like what you did before, but-
Jennifer Magley: Right, not as organized- Yeah
like an organism. I, when I have had my heart ripped out and life has, the bottom has fallen out of life, I always sit with it, sit with the reality that the world that I had created is not the world other people are living in, and that's when I always begin to kind of deconstruct and c- while constructing something else at the same time.
So whether that's a company, whether that's a project or a book, um, or a pivot in a career, I think I tend to kind of regroup, feel that pain-
Michael Zarick: Yeah ...
Jennifer Magley: and say, "I was wrong. I thought I understood how the world w- how the world works." And the other thing that I've [01:00:00] tried to do is accept the loss. 'Cause everyo- you know, for me, what I love about this quest is that no shit really happens.
You can... I got to disprove the lore of
posit- of positive toxicity, toxic positivity. Say what you want. Write it down. Be clear. Show up every day. Work as hard as you can. Don't be afraid to tell people. And I get to say, "It's all right to lose. It's all right to make f- make fun of yourself. It's okay to be humiliated and be a part of your own humiliation."
Yeah. And I don't think that that's a crisis, but I feel like that is my response to it.
Michael Zarick: Great answer. Sorry, a po- a que- a question just popped in my head. How does one book hosting a corn-eating competition? I, like, all of your thing, like- On
Jennifer Magley: your knees, begging.
Michael Zarick: You like reach out to the, the state fair board, and you're like, "Please, [01:01:00] God."
Jennifer Magley: Let me tell you. Yes. I said, "I'm already milking the cow. What other stuff you got for me on that sheet?" They said, "Well, we got the mullet competition."
Michael Zarick: Mullet?
Jennifer Magley: I said, "Do you have an emcee?" They said, "Yes." I said, "Damn it." And then, "What else you got on there?" And they said, "Corn on the cob. You can also intro- you can also introduce the, the clowns, the clown band, and the K-pop demon hunter DJ."
I said, "I'll take anything I can get." And I literally was struggling to get into the parking, because you know how they close all the gates. And I just said to myself over and over again, "This can't happen. I begged for this job." "I begged for this job." "Come on, universe, I begged for this. I can't let them down."
So that's how it happens. How do, how do I get to announce for roller derby? I went out for it. I don't know how to roller skate.
Michael Zarick: You show up
Jennifer Magley: first. I don't know how to roller skate. I go to the workshop. And that's what I've been able to do, is get into communities that other people consider to be fringe.
It turns out I thrive in there, because they're so open to accepting [01:02:00] you when you show up as yourself. Like, I am transparent in saying, "Hey, I don't wanna be a roller derby queen, I just wanna announce your, your game, and I'm doing e- everything I can. Give me a chance, Naptown." And they did. And I love them.
I love Naptown Roller Derby for that.
Michael Zarick: That's awesome. you, you, you triggered another, uh... You reminded me of a question that I had. And it's an experience that I have also, which is that you say that you don't have community personally right now, or at least you don't fully feel that way. Um, and it's something I struggle with also.
As somebody who is really interested in a multitude of things- Mm ... because I'm bouncing around, talking to as many people as I can week to week, I struggle personally to settle-
Jennifer Magley: Mm ...
Michael Zarick: and find my own space. Now I've got a little bit going on in Broad Ripple- Mm-hmm ... because that's where I live. But, um, I would say that you and I are similar in that I don't feel...
It's, it's very common that people ask me, like, "Michael, what's your favorite third space?" Yeah, of [01:03:00] course. It's like, well, I don't really feel like I have one, because I like, I try to experience everything to understand. Mm-hmm. Um, I kind of frame this podcast as, like, research for myself. do you feel like you desire to have a dedicated space, or do you like how you're positioned experiencing all these different things while never feeling fully connected to any one individual?
Jennifer Magley: Yeah. So to go to your point about a community, I have a community. The problem is that I am the sun of the every-
Michael Zarick: Back to the ego ...
Jennifer Magley: everything- You're like the
Michael Zarick: big baby in Teletubbies.
Jennifer Magley: 100%. I'm literally like, ha ha ha. So I have a community, and as somebody who has a lot of interests, and you may relate to this, I, again, I'm an empa- empathetic narcissist.
You feel bad and it's making me feel bad, so let's solve that 'cause I feel bad. But I would say that people that are my friends would hear this, they would say, "Oh my gosh, you have a community. You have a community of people that love you." But I [01:04:00] would respond and say, "But you don't know each other." That's what I mean by sun of the universe of my community, is that my varied interests mean that my friends don't know my friends.
Michael Zarick: Mm.
Jennifer Magley: And so that would be, in my, in my version, that would be the thing that connects us all, is something greater than me. Uh, and that is what is driving community rather than, "Oh yeah, I'm gonna go to this event. I know Jennifer," but I may not know the other 90 people there. Yeah, yeah. And so that's kind of like the quirk,
Michael Zarick: quirk.
Do you want to be that, um, I would call... There's a word I've used before, nexus of community. Do you want to, like, drive that forward? Like, if you are pulling those people with you, are you gonna try to create those inner, inner groups?
Jennifer Magley: I have through the lunches- Right ... 'cause it got to be too much trying to always connect people.
So it's very common for people to meet each other and then become friends, and I'm not included. Which, which
Michael Zarick: is- You're like, "
Jennifer Magley: Ah." With an introvert, which is perfect- Yeah ... 'cause I'm not going outside, right? Yeah. But to answer your question, that the root of both of my quests [01:05:00] has been I wanna be on a successful team.
I loved, oh my gosh, Michael, when I got a job at one of the biggest sports and entertainment agencies in the world right before the pandemic, I was thrilled, and then I got laid off. When I got a job as a technical recruiter and I was making, I was killing it, I was making over $200,000, which was a lot for me.
That's a lot of money. That's a lot for me. In Indiana, that's a fortune. And I got laid off again. The trauma of being laid off is so immense that I, a p- another part of this was, two years in, maybe someone will see me and want to say, "That crazy gal, let's have her on my team." And I do thrive on a team, so I do want that community of work-life team.
But again, it's Indy, so outside of a small boutique agency or a huge corporate firm, where do you fit in? And that's why you see entrepreneurship so much here. So yes, I wanna be in community. I wanna learn from other people. [01:06:00] I w- in my group of friends that know and don't know each other, I do not consider myself to be the smartest one.
I just consider myself to be the wackiest. Which is fine. Everybody needs a little Bugs Bunny in their world, you
Michael Zarick: know? It's funny that you say, uh, there, um, I always like the... Are you familiar with the, um- It's like an Albert Einstein quote or something- Hmm ... about, like, different types of intelligence. Like, you'd- Oh, okay
never ask a fish to climb a tree. Yeah. Um, something like that. Um, you say you're not the smartest, but you are the most intelligent at hosting- Hmm ... at being wacky- Thank you. That's kind ... I think. Yeah. You know what I mean? You have your skillset. I think we think of intelligence only in terms of, like, I can, like, name the parts of an atom or whatever.
Jennifer Magley: Yeah, like my husband.
Michael Zarick: Yeah.
Jennifer Magley: Perfect SAT score.
Michael Zarick: That's not what intelligence- Yes. ... truly is. Like, the dude who makes your coffee every morning has intelligence as a barista. Um, and the way we find value as people is through our collective intelligence as a community- Mm-hmm ... to use that word.
Jennifer Magley: Mm-hmm.
Michael Zarick: [01:07:00] Um, so don't, don't sell yourself short.
Jennifer Magley: Oh, no. That's kind. I mean, I do think that there's, um, levels of passion and expertise, and there's certain things that I'm like, "Hey, if you wanna learn how to get anyone in the world to respond to you, if you wanna do a hi-lo circular campaign, if you wanna do something, make your wildest dreams happen, I'm your gal.
But if you want me to help you with your fifth grade math assignment-
Michael Zarick: Hmm ...
Jennifer Magley: that's not me."
Michael Zarick: Totally. Two last questions. Uh, Jennifer, is there anything on your heart, on your mind, on your soul that would you like to bear before the listeners, that you're thinking
at this time
Jennifer Magley: I wanna make money. I wanna make more money.
Yeah, how
Michael Zarick: many of your emcee gigs are paying?
Jennifer Magley: Oh my gosh. A lot of them.
Michael Zarick: Yeah, but nothing like-
Jennifer Magley: I
mean, look, I'm just gonna break it down for you. If you're an emcee in Indianapolis and you are at around 3,000 an event, that's okay. But you're not, you're not going crazy. The [01:08:00] problem with this industry and entertainment, and I consider myself to be entertainment adjacent is that Leslie Jones in 2013, as recently as 2013, was making 100 bucks per set, and she was, you know, S- became SNL queen.
So it's not a me issue. I think it's an industry issue, and I think every creative person who's ambitious, like yourself, like anyone else who's got a side hustle, we all wanna make more money. So that is, when I say that is- Well- ... deep down in my soul, that is in my bones- I
Michael Zarick: wouldn't- ... my poet right now ... I appreciate you say money- Like-
but, like, I would just wanna make it sustainable.
Jennifer Magley: And, and, and, so-
Michael Zarick: Like, how do you, how do you make something that is, that-
Jennifer Magley: Stable, yeah ...
Michael Zarick: is, that, like, works for you?
Jennifer Magley: I want... Yes. Yeah. And that is, I am still in that space.
Michael Zarick: Yeah.
Jennifer Magley: I'm still in that space. Um-
Michael Zarick: Someone's gotta pay for all these clothes ...
Jennifer Magley: somebody's gotta pay for all these, uh, secondhand clothes.
You know the best part about secondhand clothes?
Michael Zarick: Is that- They have a story behind them? I don't know what you're gonna say
Jennifer Magley: You, you, you smell like the person who owned them before.
Michael Zarick: That's crazy.
Jennifer Magley: Sometimes I'm walking around and I'm like, "Mm, what did they have going on?" Takes a couple washes, you know? But [01:09:00] yeah, like I...
And when I say money, it's not just I wanna make $30,000 a month or 20 million net, very specifically universe, one or the other. It's literally that I wanna be able to get paid to do what I love, and they all, the... Everyone says, "Do what you love and you'll never work a day in your life." BS. We are out here grinding in these streets, and if we were only doing what we loved, math don't math.
So I think that anyone who's taking on second jobs, third jobs, first jobs to do what you love, cheers to us, and cheers to you. And hopefully we can find a way to receive that money that everyone's talking about that's looking for us somewhere.
You know?
Michael Zarick: Boom Last question. Jennifer Magley, what question would you like to ask the next Third Space Indy guest?
Jennifer Magley: If you weren't a woman, where would you be? And if you weren't a man, where would you be? Or if you didn't id- identify as how you identify, [01:10:00] where would you be? To make it politically correct.
Michael Zarick: I have to write this down.
Jennifer Magley: Give me a second. Yes. Because as I consider season three, season three might be Bitch Quest, which mic drop.
I'm looking for 365 bitches in 365 days, and that's one of the three questions in Bitch Quest, is if you weren't a woman, where would you be? So we can find out if, if the next, the next guest... And if they're a man, you can say, "If you weren't a man, where would you be?" But I do think that how we identify determines, a lot of times, our path.
And not just our path, but how we live every day. You know, what decisions we make. A lot of it is determined by that.
Michael Zarick: Definitely. I think that's... Well, I, even just like as simple as like... Well, I normally like to answer the question, but this is, that's
Jennifer Magley: a hard one. Yeah, if you weren't a man. If you- Well, the- And we, as you would say, even a white man, where would you be?
Well, the,
Michael Zarick: genuinely, like, there's so much, so many ways that I interface with the world that I- Yeah ... do [01:11:00] not think about, basically. Mm. Like, because I, again, large. Large is important here, too. Large, white man. There are so many things that I have the privilege of not thinking about, genuinely. Mm. Because I ride my bike everywhere, I take public transit a lot, I walk down streets that some people would not necessarily find the safest.
because of who I am, there's so many factors of my existence that I just get to not consider. Um, I went on a walk with a friend, um, over near Windsor Park, and she mentioned... She actually listens, so she'll know what I'm talking about. there was a path that went off to the right, and she goes, she goes, "You probably won't even think about this, but, like, I don't wanna walk down that path."
Yeah. Because it was, it was, uh, fenced off on the edges, and just, like, was pretty tight. And, uh, basically, if you were in the middle of it and someone were to block off both sides, you would have nowhere to go. And she's like- Yes ... "I would never walk through there." And I was like, "I would never even consider..."
I was like, "I [01:12:00] would probably would just, like..."
Jennifer Magley: I mean, before you go to your car at night, do you take your keys out beforehand?
Michael Zarick: What do you mean?
Jennifer Magley: When you walk from your, uh, like a restaurant, and it's nighttime, it's dark. Do you take your keys out before? Like, before you even leave the restaurant?
Michael Zarick: No.
Jennifer Magley: Every woman does that.
Every woman does that because you're afraid you gotta be able to get in your car quick. Mm. I mean, right now as I've been sitting here, we've been- I will
Michael Zarick: say I have a keyless car.
Jennifer Magley: Oh, well, yeah, yeah. Yeah, yeah. You're not big, a big baller. But, but now, you know, I, I've been, we've been sitting here yapping it up, and the entire time I've been have...
fighting off intrusives of our sons that coming home, and our alarm system has been messed up, and I'm afraid that it will call the police, and then our, our sons will be home and have to deal with all of that. Yeah.
. Yeah. And, and our kids are more melanated than me.
So it's one of those things that there's so many levels to that identification that I think the only way we learn is through reflection, and that's what your show does. It prompts people to reflect on their lives, and then the listeners think, "Hmm, what do I think about that?" And that's how we [01:13:00] grow. So thank you for making that space, and thank you for being so open to considering life outside of your own fabulous sandals-
with the painted toenails. You're not gonna see my toes. My toes- Yeah ... horror. Horror story. Oh,
Michael Zarick: I thought you were gonna say you gotta pay for them.
Jennifer Magley: Y- they're so bad you have to pay to see them. It's very niche. There's a- Usually people pay me to keep my shoes on ...
Michael Zarick: when I bought these Chacos, I bought them at Rusted Moon in Broad Ripple.
Uh-huh. Um, which is the, like, one of the only publicly owned, or publicly owned, private, or, um, one of the only locally owned outdoor stores in Indianapolis.
Jennifer Magley: Oh, wow.
Michael Zarick: Um, I was, like, sitting down changing my, uh, shoes, and I told you I have, like, a really distinct Chaco tan. Like, there is a Z- ... on my feet. Uh, and because I'm a half Lebanese Syrian, like I have a- Oh, my
Jennifer Magley: gosh
Michael Zarick: really dark skin tone from being in the sun.
Jennifer Magley: Yeah.
Michael Zarick: Yeah.
Jennifer Magley: So,
Michael Zarick: like, when I am, when I... Like, look at my arm.
Jennifer Magley: Look at you. You're not- Like, look at this farmer's
Michael Zarick: tan ... you're not
Jennifer Magley: messing around. Um. Winter is coming.
Michael Zarick: Winter is coming. I took off my shoes to, like, try [01:14:00] on these, and Brandon who works there goes, "Bro, you have a tr- crazy Chaco tan."
He just pulls out his phone and takes a picture of my feet.
Jennifer Magley: And you gave it away for free. And then he-
Michael Zarick: Were you so
Jennifer Magley: mad?
Michael Zarick: No, he posted it on Instagram, and I was like- What? ... he just posted my feet.
Jennifer Magley: Send me that. I gotta like it and share it.
Michael Zarick: I don't think he... It's, it was just in their story.
Jennifer Magley: Oh, no.
Michael Zarick: I was like, I was like, "You're posting my feet for free?"
Jennifer Magley: All, all little piggies. All 10 piggies or just 5 of them?
Michael Zarick: All 10.
Jennifer Magley: Oh.
Michael Zarick: Yeah.
Jennifer Magley: I mean, now nobody's gotta buy that milk. They got the whole cow.
Michael Zarick: I'm dying. Uh, well, Jennifer, thank you so much for coming on. It's been a true joy.
Jennifer Magley: Thank you.
Michael Zarick: Um, for anyone who wants to find you, if you want to be found-
Jennifer Magley: Oh, yeah ...
Michael Zarick: where can you be found?
Jennifer Magley: You can follow along, uh, jennifermagley on Instagram
Michael Zarick: and- Can you spell it out?
Jennifer Magley: Jennifer, M-A- M as in big mama- ... A-G as in glamorous, L-E-Y, Y as in yes. Uh, and also, if it's too much, like following me, um, I'm gonna put out a tutorial of how to unfollow me. [01:15:00] Get ready with me as I teach you how to unfollow me.
Michael Zarick: For all those housewives.
Jennifer Magley: Yes, for all those that, that think I'm after their man. You know who you are. I know-
Michael Zarick: I've heard specific names. A-
Jennifer Magley: ain't nobody want your man, girl. I'm dead.
Michael Zarick: That's so... You're like, "I got my own." Listen, listen.
Jennifer Magley: Uh, one is enough for me.
Michael Zarick: That's so funny. Anything else?
Jennifer Magley: No, just, just keep supporting local folks.
Sponsor this show, you know? That's how this, this happens.
Michael Zarick: Speak on it.
Jennifer Magley: Sponsor this show, and I'm gonna talk to you about it afterwards. I just think that in a world where the social media industrial complex is never satiated, this is an infinity loop. It takes so much to stand out, so this is why we have to keep supporting each other.
Michael Zarick: Totally. Also congratulations, uh, to future you for finishing your stage quest- Thank
Jennifer Magley: you.
Michael Zarick: Thank you ... uh, by the time this comes out. Thank you so much. So shout out to Jennifer Magley, like, two weeks ago. Uh,
Jennifer Magley: Awesome.
Michael Zarick: Yeah. Hey, thanks so much for watching or [01:16:00] listening to this episode of Third Space Indy.
You can find me by going to @thirdspaceindy on Instagram or by going to thirdspaceindy.com, where I write a show notes and a blog words. Thanks so much to City Rising for sponsoring the podcast, and thank you so much, as always, to the local artist Jennasen for allowing me to use your song Scared Rabbit as the intro song.
Thanks so much for watching or listening again. See you in the next one. Goodbye. Awesome.
Add a comment: